The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh (RCSEd) is embarking on a major digital transformation, modernising its systems, platforms, infrastructure and digital capabilities to create a seamless, resilient, user‑centred digital experience for members, exam candidates, volunteers and staff. Leading and developing a newly created multidisciplinary Digital Enablement Directorate, you will drive cultural and operational transformation focused on enhancing ways of working, strengthening governance and embedding user‑centred, evidence‑based design principles.
The HR-CEO Paradox: Right Skills, Wrong Pathways
Despite possessing skills increasingly valued in modern leadership, such as emotional intelligence, change leadership, and organisational capability, HR leaders rarely progress to CEO roles. Livingston James Director, Ali Shaw recently shared insights from our latest research report in association with EY: The Future CEO Report, and how these findings can support succession planning for HR leaders.
Our research showed that only 3% of CEOs come from an HR background, compared with significantly higher representation from operations (35%), sales/commercial (32%), and finance (19%). A recent HR Grapevine article cited our research data, arguing this is likely not due to lack of capability but to structural and perceptual barriers that position HR as a support function rather than a commercial leadership pipeline.
Data shows HR leaders tend to focus development on personal influence, visibility, and transitions, rather than enterprise-wide impact, strategic authority, and measurable business results, which are essential CEO competencies. If organisations want more CEO-ready HR leaders, they must redesign career paths to include genuine commercial responsibility, reframing HR as central to long-term business performance rather than adjacent to it.
Ultimately, it appears that HR leaders are well-equipped to lead modern organisations, but breaking the CEO glass ceiling will require:
These findings from our latest research report give an early indication of how leadership may evolve if organisations enable HR leaders to develop the full range of CEO credentials. To explore this theme in more depth, read Livingston James Director, Ali Shaw’s latest article, where he examines whether today’s uncertain economic and geopolitical environment could actually accelerate the move towards HR‑rooted CEOs, and what organisations must change to make that transition possible.
For full leadership insights from Livingston James’ latest research report in association with EY, read the 2026 Future CEO Report.
Reference:
Hayes, A. (2026). Why HR leaders almost never make it to CEO. HR Grapevine, 29 April 2026. https://www.hrgrapevine.com/content/article/2026-04-29-why-hr-leaders-almost-never-make-it-to-ceo
Can we help?
If you are looking for leadership advisory or recruitment support, please get in touch with our team of experts.
More Articles...
Livingston James is Delighted to Partner with East Park to Appoint Chief Executive
East Park is a well‑established Scottish charity delivering specialist education and care services for children and young people with complex support needs. The organisation has a long history of providing safe, nurturing environments that enable young people to develop, grow, and prepare for adulthood.
The Chief Executive will lead the organisation overall, setting clear strategic direction and overseeing day‑to‑day delivery, while working closely with the Board to secure East Park’s long‑term sustainability and positive impact.
Livingston James Partners with Acrux Gold to Recruit Head of People & Culture
Acrux Gold is a vertically integrated precious metals business and the parent company of SGZ Cononish Limited, operator of Scotland’s only commercial gold and silver mine, with operations in the UK and South Africa.
Acrux Gold is appointing a Head of People & Culture to establish and lead the people function, supporting international growth and building the capability, culture and infrastructure required for long‑term operational success.
Livingston James Retained by The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh to Appoint Director of Digital Enablement
The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh (RCSEd) is embarking on a major digital transformation, modernising its systems, platforms, infrastructure and digital capabilities to create a seamless, resilient, user‑centred digital experience for members, exam candidates, volunteers and staff. Leading and developing a newly created multidisciplinary Digital Enablement Directorate, you will drive cultural and operational transformation focused on enhancing ways of working, strengthening governance and embedding user‑centred, evidence‑based design principles.